Which AI visibility tools do AI assistants recommend? 13 days of answers
Updated
Last checked: Nov 1, 2026. The counts below come from our own daily API checks, Oct 19 to Nov 1, 2026 (published Nov 2, 2026; the Nov 2 run isn't included). Each vendor's one-line description was checked on its own website on Nov 1, 2026 (sources at the end).
Availability (Nov 2, 2026): MentionSweep's free score, $29 Full Report, $39/month Monitor and Agency plan are all live, with checkout through Stripe.
The short answer
If you ask AI assistants which AI visibility tool to use, the answer depends on which assistant you ask.
Across 339 answers to 5 neutral buyer questions over 13 run days, the tools named most were Semrush (150 answers), Ahrefs (140), Otterly.AI (130), Peec AI (124) and Profound (115). But the assistants split into two camps:
- Claude, Gemini and Perplexity named the dedicated AI visibility trackers: Otterly.AI, Peec AI, Profound, plus AthenaHQ and Scrunch (mostly Claude).
- ChatGPT through the API (with or without web search) and Grok mostly named social listening and SEO tools: Mention, Brandwatch, Google Alerts, Meltwater, Talkwalker, Brand24, Semrush and Ahrefs. ChatGPT without web search never named Otterly.AI, Peec AI or Profound in 63 answers.
So if a buyer asks ChatGPT and another buyer asks Claude, they can get two different shortlists for the same question. That's also the main lesson for any brand: check every assistant your buyers use, not just one.
How we measured it
Every day since our launch we ask the same 8 questions through the vendors' APIs (not the ChatGPT app or the other consumer apps, which can add your account, memories and location):
| Setup | How it's called | Neutral answers counted |
|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | OpenAI API, gpt-5-mini, no web search | 63 (Oct 19 to Nov 1) |
| ChatGPT + web search | OpenAI Responses API, gpt-5-mini with the web search tool | 65 (Oct 19 to Nov 1) |
| Gemini | Gemini API, no Google Search grounding | 61 (Oct 19 to Nov 1) |
| Perplexity | Perplexity Agent API, web search built in | 45 (Oct 20 to 29) |
| Claude | Anthropic API, claude-haiku-5-5, no web search | 55 (Oct 21 to Nov 1) |
| Grok | xAI API, grok-4.20, no search tools | 50 (Oct 22 to Nov 1) |
There are 13 run days: Oct 19 to 24 and Oct 26 to Nov 1 (our Oct 25 run didn't happen). Claude and Grok were added on Oct 21 and Oct 22. Perplexity has no data after Oct 29: since Oct 30 our Perplexity API calls have been refused because our account is out of paid credits, so Perplexity couldn't be checked from Oct 30 to Nov 1. Answers that failed with an API error aren't counted.
The 5 neutral questions don't name any vendor:
- What is the best AI visibility tracker?
- Is there a free AI visibility score checker that shows whether my brand appears in ChatGPT?
- What tool can I use to check if ChatGPT recommends my brand?
- What tools help a small SaaS get recommended by ChatGPT?
- How can I track brand mentions in ChatGPT? Recommend some tools.
Two more questions ask for alternatives to Otterly.AI and to Peec AI. We report those separately below, because those answers always repeat the name in the question. A script counts a tool as "named" when its name appears anywhere in the answer. Being named isn't always a recommendation: some answers mention a tool to compare against it, and some name Semrush or Ahrefs as SEO suites rather than for their AI visibility products.
The tools AI assistants named most (5 neutral questions, 339 answers)
| Tool | Answers naming it | Share | Who named it most |
|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | 150 | 44% | Claude 55 of 55, Gemini 30, ChatGPT 23 |
| Ahrefs | 140 | 41% | Claude 54 of 55, ChatGPT 23, ChatGPT + web search 19 |
| Otterly.AI | 130 | 38% | Claude 55 of 55, Gemini 49, Perplexity 25 |
| Peec AI | 124 | 37% | Claude 55 of 55, Gemini 42, Perplexity 23 |
| Profound | 115 | 34% | Gemini 50 of 61, Claude 45, Perplexity 18 |
| Mention (mention.com) | 76 | 22% | ChatGPT 29, ChatGPT + web search 16, Grok 13 |
| Brand24 | 66 | 19% | Gemini 31, ChatGPT + web search 13, Grok 11 |
| Google Alerts | 53 | 16% | ChatGPT 25, ChatGPT + web search 18 |
| Brandwatch | 51 | 15% | ChatGPT 27, ChatGPT + web search 19 |
| AthenaHQ | 48 | 14% | Claude 45, Perplexity 3 |
| Meltwater | 42 | 12% | ChatGPT 21, ChatGPT + web search 16 |
| Talkwalker | 40 | 12% | ChatGPT 19, ChatGPT + web search 13, Grok 7 |
| Scrunch | 33 | 10% | Claude 32 |
Otterly.AI is the AI search monitoring tool at otterly.ai, not Otter.ai, the meeting-notes app. Assistants mix the two up, so check which one an answer means.
What each assistant named
Top names per setup, out of that setup's answers to the 5 neutral questions:
- ChatGPT (no web search), 63 answers: Mention 29, Brandwatch 27, Google Alerts 25, Semrush 23, Ahrefs 23, Meltwater 21. Otterly.AI, Peec AI and Profound: 0. It named none of the tools we track in 18 answers.
- ChatGPT + web search, 65 answers: Ahrefs 19, Brandwatch 19, Google Alerts 18, Semrush 17, Mention 16, Meltwater 16. Peec AI 4, Profound 2, Otterly.AI 1. Turning search on didn't move it toward the dedicated trackers.
- Gemini, 61 answers: Profound 50, Otterly.AI 49, Peec AI 42, Brand24 31, Semrush 30, BrightEdge 19.
- Perplexity, 45 answers (Oct 20 to 29): Otterly.AI 25, Peec AI 23, Semrush 22, Ahrefs 18, Profound 18, HubSpot 8.
- Claude, 55 answers: Semrush, Otterly.AI and Peec AI in all 55, Ahrefs 54, Profound 45, AthenaHQ 45, Scrunch 32. Claude named the most dedicated AI visibility tools by far.
- Grok, 50 answers: Mention 13, Brand24 11, Ahrefs 8, Google Alerts 7, Talkwalker 7. It named none of the tools we track in 24 answers.
When buyers ask for alternatives
- "What are the best alternatives to Otterly.AI?" (67 answers): Profound 31, Semrush 28, Peec AI 26, Scrunch 19, Ahrefs 18, AthenaHQ 16.
- "What are the best alternatives to Peec AI?" (69 answers): Profound 38, Otterly.AI 36, AthenaHQ 26, Semrush 25, Ahrefs 19, Scrunch 19.
We've compared several of these tools on price and coverage, using each vendor's own pages: Otterly, Peec AI, Profound, AthenaHQ, Scrunch, Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit and Ahrefs Brand Radar. Each comparison says the date it was checked.
What these tools say they do
Assistants mix two kinds of tools in one list. Here is how each vendor describes itself on its own website (checked Nov 1, 2026):
Built to track AI answers
- Otterly.AI (otterly.ai): analyzes "how AI search engines mention, and cite your brand" across ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, Claude, Perplexity, Google AI Mode, Gemini and Copilot.
- Peec AI (peec.ai): "AI Search Analytics for Marketing Teams", analyzing brand performance across ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini.
- Profound (tryprofound.com): "the AI marketing platform built for the agentic era", to see what customers ask AI and measure the results.
- Ahrefs Brand Radar (ahrefs.com/brand-radar): "See ANY brand's AI visibility", across 6 AI tools.
- Semrush AI Visibility (semrush.com/ai-seo): track your AI mentions across ChatGPT, Google AI and other AI platforms.
- AthenaHQ (athenahq.ai): an "AEO & GEO platform".
- Scrunch (scrunch.com): monitor brand presence in AI search, optimize your website and deliver content to AI agents.
Built to track the web and social media
- Mention (mention.com): "Social listening & Media Monitoring tool".
- Brandwatch (brandwatch.com): a social media management, consumer intelligence and influencer marketing suite.
- Brand24 (brand24.com): an "AI Social Listening Tool" covering social media, news, blogs, videos, forums, podcasts and reviews.
- Meltwater (meltwater.com): media intelligence, social listening and AI tracking.
- Talkwalker (talkwalker.com): social listening, media monitoring and competitive intelligence.
- Google Alerts (google.com/alerts): "Monitor the web for interesting new content".
If your question is "does ChatGPT recommend my brand?", the first group is built for it. The second group tracks what people publish about you on the web and social media, which is a different job, though some of these vendors now add AI tracking too.
What to take from this
- For buyers choosing a tool: don't trust one assistant's shortlist. Ask at least two, and check each vendor's own pages for which AI engines it tracks and what it costs.
- For any brand: the same pattern applies to your category. An assistant can know your competitors well and not know you at all, and a different assistant can give the opposite answer. Check the assistants your buyers use, ask your buyers' real questions, and repeat on several days. Our guide on how to check what AI says about your brand shows how, and how to get recommended by ChatGPT covers what to do next.
Where MentionSweep stands
MentionSweep was named in none of the 475 answers to our 7 buyer questions over these 13 days. We launched on October 19, 2026, and no assistant answering these questions names us yet. We publish that because it's the point of the product: most small brands start at zero, and you can't fix what you don't measure.
MentionSweep's free score writes 10 buyer questions from what you sell, with your brand name left out, and asks ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Grok each one through their APIs without web search: 40 answers, a 0 to 100 score, and who is named instead of you. The $29 Full Report is a one-time check of 50 questions that adds Perplexity, with share of voice against up to 3 competitors and the sites AI cites. Monitor ($39/month) re-checks every week.
More guides: free AI visibility checkers and Grok visibility checkers.
A note on accuracy
These are API answers to a fixed set of questions on 13 days, counted by name matching, so they show a pattern, not a ranking of which tool is best. The consumer apps can answer differently. Counts per setup are small, and assistants don't give the same answer twice. MentionSweep isn't affiliated with OpenAI, Google, Anthropic, xAI, Perplexity or any vendor named on this page.
Sources
- MentionSweep daily API checks, Oct 19 to Nov 1, 2026 (no Oct 25 run): 8 fixed questions, 6 setups; counts of tool names in each answer.
- Vendor self-descriptions, each from the vendor's own website on Nov 1, 2026: otterly.ai, peec.ai, tryprofound.com, ahrefs.com/brand-radar, semrush.com/ai-seo, athenahq.ai, scrunch.com, mention.com, brandwatch.com, brand24.com, meltwater.com, talkwalker.com, Google Alerts.
- Free score and plan details from our own product.
Want to see which brands ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Grok name when your buyers ask? Get your free AI visibility score.